I hardly ever make even “healthy” desserts because I know myself and I know my small amount of self control that I have. If I make a dessert I have a hard time not eating the whole thing. Because of this, lately I just stay away. These peanut butter cups are no different. They are TOO AMAZING. I might have to hide the rest of them. I’m sitting here staring at 7 of them (cause I definitely ate 2) wanting them to disappear so I don’t eat them.
These are gluten-free and if you use dairy-free chocolate they are dairy-free. They are not Paleo. Sadly peanuts are a legume and not a nut, but if you soak your peanuts for 24 hours and then dehydrate before roasting to make peanut butter, you may tolerate them even if you don’t usually do well with legumes.
1 (10 oz) bag chocolate chips, bittersweet preferably to decrease sugar
1-2 tbsp coconut oil
1 cup peanut butter
1/2 cup powdered sugar (or less if trying to cut back!)
1/4 cup maple syrup
3 tbsp butter
9 full sized muffin liners in muffin tin
Put chocolate chips in double boiler or on very low heat on stove to melt with coconut oil. Make sure to stir consistently, at least every minute or two. Meanwhile, add the rest of the ingredients to a mixer and mix until creamy, scraping sides with spatula as necessary.
When chocolate is melted, stir and make sure it's creamy and liquid, adding more coconut oil to make it more liquid-y. then, take a spoon and cover bottom of muffin liners, pressing into sides so chocolate goes slightly up side. After completing 9, put in freezer until hardened, about 2 minutes.
After the chocolate is hardened, take a small cookie dough or ice cream scoop, and scoop peanut butter on top of hardened ice cream, pressing down until flat, but leaving some space between peanut butter and sides of muffin tin. Then, pour the rest of the chocolate over top until covered (may have to reheat). Put in freezer for another 10-15 minutes until fully hardened. At this point the cups should be able to easily be peeled from the wrappers for pretty presentation. Enjoy!